(Approx 2 minute 30 second read)

In the world of martial arts, grades, are viewed as a reflection of a practitioner’s journey – a combination of technical ability, deeper understanding, and personal character.
.
Yet, there are times when we encounter individuals whose grade seems to far outshine their skills, knowledge, or behavior. Such instances can evoke frustration and even anger, particularly when the values of integrity and respect, so deeply rooted in the martial arts we all practice, appear compromised.
.
Although a grade or belt is an agreement between you, an instructor, or organization, you represent what they teach, and should be an indicator of your knowledge and dedication to that particular style, or group. Nothing more.
.
If I turned up at your dojo or club, I know my grade and title would mean very little in the scheme of things, as there are no universal standards.
.
Recently, I witnessed someone being elevated to the rank of 4th dan. Despite displaying a lack of deeper understanding, limited technical ability, and questionable behavior towards students, it was, in my opinion, and I know this person, this rank felt undeserved. However, it’s really none of my business.
.
I’m not under any illusions of course, I know that money talks. But, I do admit to feeling irritated. I shouldn’t I know. However, a grade of this level is meant to signify not only proficiency but a deep connection to the principles of the martial arts. When those principles are absent, it undermines the integrity of the grade itself.
.
A belt or title is not just a mark of technical proficiency, it should symbolize the bearer’s dedication to self-improvement, humility, and their treatment of others. Especially if they teach, with a deeper connection to the art they practice. When someone’s grade does not align with these ideals, it’s easy to feel disheartened with the whole system.
.
However, we must remember that grade alone does not define a martial artist. Their actions, knowledge, and attitude, ultimately speak louder than any title they hold. And in this instance, well, I best not say any more.
.
Each of us walks our own path, shaped by our experiences, mentors, and personal growth. Another person’s grade – whether deserved or not – does not diminish the value of our own journey. So we shouldn’t dwell on the actions of others – like opinions – at the end of the day it really doesn’t matter.
.
Ultimately, your martial arts journey is one of authenticity. Those who earn their grades through genuine effort and dedication will always stand apart from those who do not. Time has a way of revealing the truth. A grade without substance is hollow, and people will eventually see it for what it is.
.
Of course, there are those that flaunt the system, and I know a few of those. Sadly, grades can be given for political and financial reasons too.
.
When I look around me at the highly skilled and knowledgeable practitioners, I often feel unworthy of my grade. I’m under no illusions that it isn’t worth very much outside of my own group. Perhaps that’s all that matters. And this new 4th dan realizes that too. Knowing him though, I doubt it.
.
Anyway, let us focus on our own growth, set an example for others, and uphold the integrity of the art we hold dear. Let’s try to remain grounded in respect and humility.
.
Promotions like these remind me of gravity: what goes up, eventually comes crashing down. Hopefully, they’re prepared for the landing.
.
.
Written by Adam Carter – Shuri Dojo