Following my recent article on bunkai and choreography, I found myself returning to the idea of “predictable responses”. It’s a familiar concept, and on the surface it makes sense. Certain actions often provoke certain reactions. . But often isn’t always. Nothing is guaranteed. . Yes, bodies respond to input. Strike, pull, disrupt balance – something…
Category: Development
Bunkai Without Reaction Is Still Choreography.
Bunkai – in some circles it is getting better. Practitioners and instructors are beginning to understand the reality of violence rather than relying on the familiar, stylized karate-type attacks. Intent, distance, and targets are improving. In others, however, there is still a long way to go. . But something fundamental is still missing in many…
What Do We Mean When We Say “Original Kata”?
This question comes up again and again in karate, usually after a video is shared or a book is mentioned. Someone performs a kata and the discussion quickly turns into claims about what is “original”, who learned from whom, and who was closest to the source. Before long, the kata itself is almost forgotten, replaced…
“Take Them to the Ground” That Is The Failure
Some of the messages I receive are incredibly short-sighted. “You would fail if you were taken to the ground.” . Firstly – fail at what? . I don’t compete anymore. The karate I teach, and have taught for several decades, is practical and pragmatic in approach. Yes, we occasionally have fun and do competition-style sparring,…
Karate Doesn’t Fail – Unclear Goals Do.
The global estimate of people who practice martial arts ranges from as low as 50 million to as high as 150 million. . So what is it that all these people see in the martial arts? . Despite those numbers, the vast majority of practitioners will never use their skills in a real act of…
Certificates, Curiosity, and the Disappearance of Depth in Karate.
There is a modern belief that achievement is something you can hold in your hand – a certificate, a diploma, a grade, a title, a rank. Something printed, stamped, and signed that proves you have arrived. It’s a comforting illusion, and it has taken root in karate. . The logic is simple. If the box…
When Function Comes First – Kata as Record, Not Puzzle.
History is a strange thing. We have snippets here and there, sometimes probabilities creep in, but very little that is truly concrete. We study, we interpret, and some attempt to reverse engineer, but at the end of the day we can only work with what we have now. . There is an ongoing discussion around…
Real Violence Isn’t a Fight – And That Changes Everything.
In response to my recent article about a video of a practitioner demonstrating self-defense techniques, coming from a respected karate legacy, a comment stated that it is virtually impossible to train for real-world encounters, and that even MMA fighters lose in street situations. . Statements like this often sound insightful, but they hide a deeper…
Choreography and the Dangers of Untested Confidence.
I was watching a video of a practitioner going through some self-defense techniques, presented as coming from a respected karate legacy. . To be honest, it would have been totally ineffective for that goal. . In a recent article, I explained how, as a young man in my early 20s, actively competing at a national…
What Seniority Was Meant to Represent – When Titles Outpace Training.
Karate has always been a long road. It was never meant to be a collection of certificates to gather, but a lifetime of practice that slowly shapes the person who walks it. . The early grades mark progress, but they are only the beginning. Shodan literally means “first step”, the point at which you finally…
Training for What You Can’t Predict – When Practice Meets Reality.
In a previous article, I wrote about how suddenly violence can appear, and how little control any of us may have over its arrival. . I also wrote about an incident from my early twenties, when I was attacked while out running. That experience stayed with me not because of technique, but because of what…
The Part of Violence Few Train For: Prepared for Practice, Not for Shock.
Yesterday, a seventy-eight-year-old man was gunned down in his own home near where I live. What does this have to do with martial arts? . Nothing. . And yet, it has everything to do with awareness. . Would awareness have saved this man? Probably not. And that matters. Not every act of violence is preventable,…